Waterfront Lake House & Cottage Rentals

Oak Orchard Stay offers comfortable, thoughtfully designed rooms and vacation rentals directly on the water along Oak Orchard Creek in Point Breeze and Waterport, NY. Our waterfront location places guests steps from world-class trout and salmon fishing, boating, and paddling, with Lake Ontario just beyond the harbor. Whether you’re visiting for a fishing trip, a weekend escape, or a relaxing stay by the creek, Oak Orchard Stay provides an inviting place to unwind in the heart of Western New York.

BOOK YOUR STAY

Cozy bedroom with two beds, white bedding, striped pillow, gray curtains, wall shelves, and decorative items.

Vacation & Full-Home Rental on Oak Orchard Creek

Looking for a waterfront place to stay in Orleans County? Oak Orchard Stay offers private, full-home vacation rentals directly on Oak Orchard Creek, including our Lake House and Catfish Cottage, ideal for fishing trips, boating weekends, and extended stays by the water. Located between Rochester and Buffalo, our homes provide the space, comfort, and direct water access travelers and anglers value most, with the creek, harbor, and Lake Ontario just steps away.

Curved blue wavy line on white background
Check Room Availability
Cozy bedroom with gray walls, white bed, wooden ceiling, and rustic decor including a wicker basket and lamps.
Snow-covered Adirondack chairs surrounding a firepit near a river, with a dock, bare trees, and a grill in the background.
Dark blue wavy line on a white background
The Lake House
Kitchen countertop with black utensil holder, knives, and a black container with kitchen utensils. Open wooden shelves with plates, bowls, and glassware.
Dining area with wooden table, black chairs, double window, gray wall, modern black light fixture, and staircase with white-walled railings and wooden steps.
A cozy bedroom with nautical decor, including a white bed with striped pillows, a wall-mounted anchor, and a window with blue and white striped curtains. There is a small sign on a desk displaying Wi-Fi information.
A cozy bedroom with a white bed, gray wall, window with blinds, wicker storage chest at foot of bed, and a wooden ceiling.

Looking for More Room?

If you’re traveling with a larger group or planning a gathering that needs more room, our nearby partner property, Fairhaven Inn, offers additional accommodations and event space. With newly renovated rooms and flexible gathering areas, it’s a convenient option for guests who need extra space beyond our waterfront homes.

Dark blue wavy line on white background
VIEW FAIRHAVEN

  • "This was a beautiful hidden gem. The owner was very accommodating. It was perfect!"

    - Amanda Kroening

  • "We have stayed there several years, beautiful house and location. Owner is very helpful and keeps a wonderful property."

    - Ben McBratney

  • "Absolutely adorable!! This cottage was perfect for our stay and spotless! I hate to give such a good review because I would like to keep this gem a secret so that it would be available whenever we come to town!"

    - Becky Murphy